Commodities Exposure Can Help Investors Play Defense
Commodities ETFs can add a different kind of exposure than stocks or bonds, but the investment case depends on how the underlying basket is built. In practice, a broad commodities fund may be driven by a handful of sectors or contracts, while a more targeted vehicle can lean heavily on one theme such as energy-transition metals. That means the label โcommoditiesโ can hide very different risk profiles.
Index methodology matters because it shapes what investors actually own. A rules-based benchmark may select miners, producers, or futures-linked instruments, each of which responds differently to inflation, rates, and supply disruptions. For long-term allocators, the key question is not simply whether commodities are defensive, but whether the specific index captures the intended source of exposure without unintended concentration.
Fund structure is another important filter. Commodity ETFs may hold operating companies, use a securities basket, or access exposure through other implementation methods. These structures can affect tracking behavior, turnover, and how closely the fund follows its benchmark. Investors should also watch for liquidity in the underlying market, since narrow segments can widen trading frictions even when the ETF itself looks active.
For portfolio construction, the main value of commodities is often as a complement rather than a core holding. The asset class can behave differently from broad equity exposure, but it also brings sharper drawdown risk and periodic cyclicality. That makes rebalancing discipline important: the goal is usually to maintain a measured allocation that can help diversify shocks, not to chase a single macro outcome.
Volatility during the month of September could pave the way for defensive portfolio moves, which include getting commodities exposure. Also, itโs historically been a sound strategy, according to data from S&P.
In particular, the performance of the S&P GSCI the past 50 years has shown that during times of heavy inflation, getting commodities exposure has been a defensively sound move.
โThere have each been three periods where sustained monetary policy was either restrictive or accommodative, covering 50 of the 53 years since 1970,โ the S&P blog noted, mentioning that in โover two-thirds of the sample, average annualized returns were over 10.5%. This covers the inflationary bouts of the 1970โs, the commodity super cycle of the 2000โs and one particularly short and abysmal year in 2018/2019.โ
In todayโs market, inflation is proving to be a lot more sticky and stubborn than initially anticipated at the start of the year. With high hopes heading into 2023, the market rally has been losing its steam heading into the fourth and final quarter of the year.
As such, it may be an opportune time to get commodities exposure even if the Fed does eventually start loosening its monetary policy. Until then, there could be more volatility ahead as investors expect more rate hikes to come.
โLooking at the history of the S&P GSCI, when the Fed gets defensive, commodities have tended to be a good offense,โ the S&P blog said further, adding that commodity performance has been erratic lately, but that the โS&P GSCI achieved a 22% return in 2022, outpacing all asset classesโ and if โthe Fed remain restrictive, historical commodity returns have proven to be a solid defensive strategy.โ
Consider Critical Minerals for Commodities Exposure
While there are various commodities investors can consider to get defensive, one consideration is critical minerals. Investors can also get an added growth component as the world transitions to heavier reliance on clean energy sources.
โThat commodity supercycle is being driven by not the bulk commodities that we saw in the 2000s, but energy transition-related commodities, because energy transition, if the worldโs serious about doing it, is incredibly raw material intensive,โ said John Ciampaglia, CEO of Sprott Asset Management. โWe believe if the secular decarbonization of economies theme continues to play out over the next 20-30 years, the demand side story is likely to be very robust for critical minerals including uranium to battery metals to copper.โ
Given this, one fund to consider isย theย Sprott Energy Transition Materials ETF (SETM). SETM seeks to provide results that correspond to the total return performance of the Nasdaq Sprott Energy Transition Materials Index. That index essentially tracks the performance of a selection of global securities in the energy transition materials industry.
The demand for overall critical minerals is projected to rise. With it, the demand for miners who materially affect the global supply will also increase. Given this, SETM provides investors access to the miners who produce uranium, lithium, copper, nickel, silver, manganese, cobalt, graphite, and rare earth elements.
For more news, information, and analysis, visit theย Gold/Silver/Critical Materials Channel.
Enjoyed this article? Sign up for our newsletter to receive regular insights and stay connected.
