Check it Out: Harbor’s Active High-Yield ETF, SIHY
Active high-yield ETFs are best judged by process, not slogans. For investors comparing similar bond funds, the real question is whether the manager’s security-selection framework can add enough value to justify accepting an extra layer of decision-making. In high yield, that matters because return is often driven as much by credit selection and default control as by broad market beta.
Cost is only one part of implementation. An ETF with a modest fee still needs to be evaluated for how efficiently it trades its underlying bonds. In less liquid credit markets, the portfolio can face wider bid-ask spreads, higher turnover, and tracking differences versus the index or category benchmark. Those frictions may be small in calm markets but can become more visible when liquidity tightens.
Composition also deserves attention. High-yield funds are rarely “diversified” in the same way as broad equity ETFs; they can remain concentrated by issuer, industry, or credit quality. That means investors should look beyond yield and examine how the fund balances lower-rated names, sector exposure, and issuer limits. A disciplined process can help, but it does not remove the portfolio’s sensitivity to refinancing risk and credit cycles.
For long-term allocators, the key decision is role and sizing. An active high-yield ETF may fit as a satellite income sleeve rather than a core fixed-income holding. Rebalancing matters because credit spreads and risk appetite can shift quickly, altering the fund’s weight in a broader portfolio. Investors who use it should be clear about what they want it to do: enhance income, diversify equity risk, or add a more flexible credit approach.
According to Harbor and BlueCove in a recent webcast, Harbor’s high-yield bond ETF showcases the potential strength in active management.
The Harbor Scientific Alpha High-Yield ETF (SIHY C) is an active ETF offering distinct exposure to the high-yield bond market. The fund seeks to provide total returns by employing a structured investment process that utilizes a proprietary model-based framework in the security selection of high-yield bonds.
Notably, investors don’t have to pay more for active management. SIHY charges a total expense ratio of 48 basis points. That is one basis point less than its largest high-yield bond ETF Morningstar category peer.
BlueCove, SIHY’s subadvisor, is a scientific asset management firm that focuses on active management. The firm was founded with the specific goal of seeking to deliver compelling investment outcomes for investors by researching, developing, and implementing scientific investment processes applicable to fixed income investment management.
“Scientific investing is the implementation of an evidence-based investment process, that is data-driven, economically intuitive, and grounded in the scientific method,” according to Heather DeGarmo, head of product strategy at BlueCove.
“The scientific method for reference here is really around this idea to have a hypothesis, test it, implement it. See how I did, and rinse, refine, repeat,” DeGarmo added.
Many investors are underexposed to bonds as they haven’t looked particularly attractive in years past. However, high-yield bond strategies are currently seeing a resurgence in interest, and for good reason. According to DeGarmo, for many asset management professionals, it’s the first time in their careers that she believes it’s possible to generate high single-digit or low double-digit returns from liquidly traded public assets.
“If you have historically had a non-active or a lower allocation to active fixed income, that’s not surprising,” DeGarmo said.
In addition to SIHY’s recent outperformance, Harbor Capital’s internal data science team has studied active management’s performance by decades.
Paul Herbert, a managing director on Harbor Capital’s investment research team, said the team looked at rolling one-year excess returns of active managers versus their Morningstar category benchmarks from the 2000s, the 2010s, and the 2020s.
According to Herbert, the results of the study suggest active management results have improved in the 2020s versus the 2010s. “We expect this to persist given macro uncertainty and elevated volatility,” Herbert added.
For more news, information, and analysis, visit the Market Insights Channel.
Enjoyed this article? Sign up for our newsletter to receive regular insights and stay connected.
