Diversifying Commodities Rise 16% In Q3 2023 As Equities Drop
For ETF investors, the key takeaway is that โcommoditiesโ is not a single bet. Broad commodity ETFs can behave very differently depending on how the benchmark is built. A production-weighted index can end up dominated by energy, which means the fund may be acting less like a balanced commodity sleeve and more like an energy-heavy inflation proxy. That construction choice matters when investors are trying to diversify equity and bond risk.
The diversification case is strongest when the allocation is sized and held for portfolio reasons, not for tactical excitement. Commodities have historically been used to reduce dependence on traditional risk assets because their drivers are often different from those of stocks and bonds. But the same feature that helps in stress periods can also produce uneven results: a commodity allocation may cushion one macro shock while lagging badly in another, especially when the mix of sectors shifts inside the index.
Macro variables also shape how commodity ETFs interact with the rest of a portfolio. A stronger U.S. dollar, rising real rates and changing inflation expectations can all pressure parts of the complex, particularly precious metals and agriculture. Investors should therefore look beyond the headline โcommoditiesโ label and consider what risk factor they are actually adding: inflation sensitivity, energy exposure, or a broader raw-materials basket tied to global growth.
For long-term planning, the main decision is not whether commodities are always โgoodโ or โbad,โ but whether they improve the portfolio mix. That means thinking about concentration, rebalancing discipline and how the ETFโs benchmark may tilt the sleeve toward one sector at the expense of others. In multi-asset portfolios, the role of commodities is usually about portfolio construction first and return chasing second.
ย
champc
Commodities, as represented by the S&P GSCI, rose over 4% in September and 16% in Q3 2023. This highlighted the potential diversification qualities of this asset class, as equities and fixed income both fell during the month.
Commoditiesโ low correlations to other asset classes can provide a cushion when other higher-allocated asset classes drop during risk-off scenarios as was seen last month.
Adding commodities to a strategy tends to dampen overall portfolio risk and drawdowns over time. Historically, during periods of great macroeconomic shifts like we are experiencing now, a diversified portfolio has tended to perform better than more highly concentrated ones.
During periods of high and sticky inflation readings, commodities have provided a hedge when other asset classes tend to drop from higher input costs.
ย
The main contributors to the outsized performance last month were the energy commodities. Supply cuts from Saudi Arabia and Russia were the strongest catalysts as demand persisted globally.
The headline S&P GSCI currently has a weight in energy commodities of over 60% due to its construction as a world production-weighted index.
Market participants replicating it as an inflation hedge witnessed higher returns recently in comparison to other comparable commodity indices, which tend to be more equally weighted.
Energy commodities tend to have the highest inflation beta or sensitivity to changes in inflation over time. Other commodities used in petroleum products such as sugar also rose by 5%, with its heavy use in ethanol in South America.
The S&P GSCI Industrial Metals rose 3.51% in the third quarter, with the five metalsโ prices continuing to bounce back from tough first half 2023 performances.
Expectations for Chinaโs economy to accelerate were never met, but stimulus measures are slowly being introduced. China tends to be the biggest contributor to metal demand and this has the potential to still be the case during the energy transition.
The International Energy Agency (IEA) updated its Net Zero Roadmap in September, when it said electricity is poised to emerge as the new oil of the global energy system.
Metal demand will likely pick up over time due to the use of certain industrial, precious and rare earth metals increasing by many times more across a wide span of clean energy technologies.
The S&P GSCI Agriculture fell 4.35% and the S&P GSCI Precious Metals fell 3.76% in the third quarter. Both sectors, along with most commodities, were hit by the headwind of a rising U.S. dollar.
For the agriculture commodities, lower soybean usage and surprisingly larger wheat production figures were reported in the latest USDA quarterly stocks report.
Within the precious metals, gold and silver both fell as real rates continued to rise.
Gold tends to be inversely correlated to real rates but this hasnโt been the case for most of 2023. Recent heavy central bank bullion buying may have been the reason for goldโs resilience so far in 2023.
Disclosure: Copyright ยฉ 2023 S&P Dow Jones Indices LLC, a division of S&P Global. All rights reserved. This material is reproduced with the prior written consent of S&P DJI. For more information on S&P DJI, please visit S&P Dow Jones Indices. For full terms of use and disclosures, please visit Terms of Use.
Editor’s Note: The summary bullets for this article were chosen by Seeking Alpha editors.
Enjoyed this article? Sign up for our newsletter to receive regular insights and stay connected.
