This Is No Time For Celebration, The Oil Rally Is Just Getting Started

For ETF investors, the key question is not whether oil is โ€œupโ€ or โ€œdown,โ€ but how that move is being expressed through the fund structure. Many oil ETFs gain exposure through futures rather than physical barrels, which means the shape of the futures curve can matter as much as the spot price. In a tightening market, backwardation can support short-term roll outcomes, but it also reminds investors that headline commodity moves and ETF performance are not the same thing.

That distinction is especially important for long-term holders. Commodity ETFs are usually best understood as tactical tools, not permanent core holdings. Their return paths can be affected by contract rolling, collateral income, and the timing of rebalancing. Even when the underlying commodity theme is constructive, the fund can experience periods of tracking difference simply because it is repeatedly moving from one futures contract to the next.

Oil exposure also deserves a portfolio-level lens. Energy can provide diversification when inflation, supply shocks, or geopolitical stress dominate markets, but it can also increase volatility if sized too aggressively. Investors should think in terms of role: hedge, satellite allocation, or short-duration tactical position. That framing helps avoid turning a commodity trade into an oversized bet on a single macro variable.

The practical takeaway is discipline. Before using an oil ETF, check whether the product holds futures, how often it rolls, and whether the mandate is designed for short-term trading or strategic exposure. In commodity ETFs, the mechanism is the message: fund structure, curve dynamics, and rebalancing rules often determine whether the investor gets the exposure they expected.




ย 

Torsten Asmus

In our WCTW this Monday, we wrote that the oil market (CL1:COM) is not prepared for what’s coming. The U.S. has, in essence, bailed out the rest of the world from an oil supply shortage, but that is about to come to an end. With U.S. crude storage failing to build and likely trend lower by mid-October, U.S. crude exports should fall. The combination of falling U.S. crude exports coupled with Saudi and Russia’s voluntary cuts should send the physical oil market into a frenzy.

We are already seeing eye-popping backwardation, and there’s more to come.

barcharts.com

If you thought March/April 2022 was bad, you haven’t seen the real thing yet. We are talking about real supply cuts this time, not some fantasy potential supply drop.

What makes this time even more beautiful is that the IEA will be well behind the eight ball. As we wrote in our report two weeks ago, IEA really messed up by assuming massive builds in H1 2024. What they should’ve done instead is caution everyone that the market is about to get very tight. But nope, as a political outfit now more than an energy agency, it chose a completely different path, one that should inevitably lead the world into a crisis.

And similar to the path the IEA took when Russia invaded Ukraine telling the world that Russian oil production would fall by ~3 million b/d, this time around, it is preaching the exact opposite: ample supply.

But as the title of this OMF suggests, this is no time for celebration, this is no time for pats on the back, because this is only just getting started.

EIA, HFIR

Our latest U.S. crude storage forecast shows non-existent crude builds during refinery maintenance season. We have one last rush of U.S. crude exports and that’s it. U.S. crude storage will likely stay flat to higher into year-end because U.S. crude exports will fall. This is what we expect and the end result is a much tighter global oil market environment.

So for readers trying to stay ahead of the curve, please do not expect U.S. commercial crude storage to fall well below ~400 million bbls. We are already tight and so the market will force relief one way or another.

Dominos are falling…

One of the bear factors was demand, but demand is holding up well. Unlike some of the bulls argue, we don’t see demand as being robust, but it’s not terrible like the bears are claiming. Refining margins will continue to remain under pressure as crude tightness gets even tighter. Bears will point to falling refining margins as a sign of demand weakness, when in reality, it’s just crude tightness.

Oil, in the meantime, will continue to climb the wall of worries. Recession, high interest rates, lower refining margins, OPEC+ spare capacity, all of these things will prevent people from seeing the bigger picture, and that’s that the marginal supply has all but peaked.

HFIR

And the U.S., being the largest growth in supply over the last decade, is all but on its last leg. The oil market is firmly in the hands of the Saudis and they can do however they please going forward.

So this is no time for celebration because it’s only just getting started. Buckle up, extreme tightness in the physical market is coming.


Original Post

Enjoyed this article? Sign up for our newsletter to receive regular insights and stay connected.