2 Commodity ETFs to Keep Client Portfolios Diversified
Commodity ETFs can play a portfolio role that is different from stocks and bonds: they are not primarily about income or growth, but about adding another return driver whose behavior may diverge when inflation, supply shocks, or geopolitical stress move markets. That diversification benefit, however, depends on whether the fund spreads exposure broadly or leaves the portfolio leaning on a narrow slice of the commodity complex.
The main distinction for investors is not just โcommodities versus commodities,โ but how the exposure is built. Broad baskets typically use futures-based index rules or managed roll approaches to avoid concentrating too much in a single contract month or a single raw material. That matters because the structure can influence tracking behavior, rollover costs, and how closely the ETF mirrors the intended exposure over time.
Costs and tax mechanics also matter more here than in many equity ETFs. Commodity funds can carry higher fees than plain-vanilla index products, and the after-cost experience can be meaningfully affected by futures management and the way distributions are handled. Investors comparing products should look beyond the headline expense ratio and consider whether the fundโs tax reporting and trading setup fit the account in which it will be held.
For long-term portfolio planning, the key question is not whether commodities are โhot,โ but whether the sleeve is sized and diversified appropriately. A commodity ETF can help balance a portfolio, but it should be used as a complement to core equity and bond holdings rather than a substitute for them.
Many investors are rushing into gold or energy commodity ETFs to try to capture the current opportunity set โ a strategy thatโs not guaranteed to pay off.
In the current environment, characterized by uncertainty and unknown unknowns, diversification is key. A broad-basket commodity ETF offers exposure to the asset class without placing significant bets on certain commodities.
Instead of placing bets on individual commodities, investors can get diversified exposure to the asset class with theย Invesco Optimum Yield Diversified Commodity Strategy No K-1 ETF (PDBC)ย and theย Invesco DB Commodity Index Tracking Fund (DBC).
PDBC
PDBC is the largest commodity ETF available to investors, with $5.6 billion in assets under management.
The fund is unique in that itโs actively managed, providing exposure to the worldโs most heavily traded commodities. The fundโs greatest commodity allocations as of September 29 are brent crude (13.84%), WTI crude (13.31%), gasoline (12.30%), NY Harbor ULSD (10.79%), and sugar (9.21%).
DBC
While PDBC is the largest ETF in the category, DBC is a heavyweight itself. DBC is the third-largest commodity ETF by assets under management, with $2.2 billion.
DBC tracks the DBIQ Optimum Yield Diversified Commodity Index plus the interest income from the fundโs holdings of primarily U.S. Treasury securities and money market income (less the fundโs expenses). DBCโs underlying index provides exposure to 14 heavily traded commodities across the energy, precious metals, industrial metals, and agriculture sectors.
DBCโs current allocations look similar to PDBC, with slightly different weights. As of September 29, DBCโs five largest exposures by weight include WTI crude (13.00%), Brent crude (12.77%), gasoline (12.08%), NY Harbor ULSD (11.81%), and sugar (9.60%).
An important difference between the two commodity ETFs is that DBC issues a schedule K-1. Thus, many investors might opt for PDBC to get exposure to commodity futures without the tax hassle of a K-1.
PDBC charges 59 basis points while DBC charges 87 basis points.
Enjoyed this article? Sign up for our newsletter to receive regular insights and stay connected.
