Industrial Metals Sector Boosts Commodities

For ETF investors, the important point is not just that commodities moved higher, but why one broad index behaved differently from another. When two benchmark-tracking products hold different sector weights, the result can be a meaningful gap in returns even over a single quarter. Here, industrial metals helped the index with the larger allocation to that sleeve, while a heavier precious-metals and energy mix supported the other benchmark.

That makes composition a first-order decision. Commodity ETFs and index funds are not interchangeable simply because they both offer โ€œcommoditiesโ€ exposure. Investors should look at whether the fund emphasizes energy, industrial metals, precious metals, agriculture or livestock, because those exposures can change the portfolioโ€™s sensitivity to inflation, growth, weather, and supply disruptions. A broad label can hide a very different risk profile.

Roll methodology is the second layer to watch. For futures-based commodity funds, performance is influenced not only by spot price changes but also by how contracts are rolled along the curve. In flatter curve environments, a disciplined roll process can help reduce drag or even add support relative to a benchmark with a different design. That structural feature may matter more than short-term headlines.

For long-term allocators, commodities remain a diversification tool rather than a standalone destination. Their role is usually tied to portfolio balancing, inflation sensitivity, and periodic reweighting as macro conditions change. Investors comparing commodity ETFs should therefore focus on methodology, sector mix, and roll mechanics before making an allocation decision.


This past quarter, industrial metals was the strongest sector. Looking ahead, we believe commodity prices could continue to rally due to a possible U.S. easing and rising geopolitical risks.

Roll Yield Maintained Positiveย Performance

The UBS Constant Maturity Commodity Index (CMCITR) was up 1.89% during the second quarter but underperformed the Bloomberg Commodity Index (BCOM), which was up 2.89%. However, year-to-date, CMCITR outperformed BCOM by more than 2% (7.17% versus 5.14%). While BCOMโ€™s outperformance during the quarter was mostly attributed to a larger allocation in natural gas and precious metals commodities, CMCITR outperformed in roll yield. CMCITRโ€™s curve positioning and roll methodology continue to outperform BCOM in a relatively flat roll yieldย environment.

CMCITR Outperformed in Q2 2024 Due to Roll Yieldย Contribution

CMCITR Outperformed in Q2 2024 Due to Roll Yieldย Contribution

Source: Bloomberg.ย Data as of June 2024. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Index performance is not illustrative of fund performance. It is not possible to invest in anย index.

Sector Lookback: Industrial Metals: Strongest Sector inย Q2

Natural gas, WTI crude oil and Brent crude oil led the energy sector in Q2. U.S. natural gas prices rose sharply primarily due to extremely warm weather in the U.S. and the continued war in Ukraine. WTI crude oil and Brent crude oil both rose about 2% in the quarter, however, products such as gasoil, heating oil, and unleaded gas, were slightlyย lower. The agriculture sector declined in Q2, with only wheat and coffee being higher. Cocoa prices fell but were still up sharply for the year. BCOMโ€™s zero allocation to cocoa ensured no negative contribution to performance for the quarter; however, the index missed out on the year-to-date contribution when the commodity showed returns of 100%. Corn was down 10% and soybeans were down around 5%, which had negative impacts on the agriculture sector duringย Q2. The industrial metals sector was the strongest in Q2, with total returns of around 9%. Copper increased 10% and zinc 21%, both of which were the strongest performers. CMCITRโ€™s higher allocation to the sector helped relative performance versus BCOM but did not offset BCOMโ€™s outperformance in energy and preciousย metals. The precious metals sector rose in Q2 by 7%. Silver led the sector, increasing about 18% in the quarter. BCOM has a higher allocation to precious metals than CMCITR. Although the precious metals sector holds the smallest weight in both indices, its overweight in BCOM (20%) added positive contribution to returns (+1.1%) over CMCITR (weight: 6.3%). The livestock sector fell in Q2 due to a decline of 11% in lean hog prices, which offset a small gain in live cattleย prices.

Comparative Index Sectorย Weights

CMCITRโ€™s higher weighting to Industrial Metals helped relative performance in Q2 2024 Comparative Index Sectorย Weights

Source:ย VanEck, Bloomberg. Data as of June 2024.

Outlook: Can Commodity Prices Continue to Rally?

Commodity prices could continue to rally in the second half of the year. The U.S. economy started to slow down in Q2, raising the chances of the Federal Reserve (Fed) cutting interest rates in September 2024. If that happens, it is expected that the U.S. dollar will decline, thus helping to push commodity prices higher in the fall and winter. In addition to a possible U.S. easing, global geopolitical risks are rising. Concerns surrounding the candidatesโ€™ suitability for the U.S. presidential election later could also cause geopolitical risks to rise even further in the second half of 2024.
https://www.etftrends.com/tactical-allocation-channel/industrial-metals-sector-boosts-commodities/

Enjoyed this article? Sign up for our newsletter to receive regular insights and stay connected.