Diversifying within Equities before Diversifying Away from Them

Infographic titled “Market Analysis & Strategies in 2026” showing S&P 500 gains, investment strategies, headwinds, and risk-screened stocks.

Defensive equity ETFs are not a substitute for diversification, but they can change where the equity risk sits. In a concentrated benchmark, the headline index return can hide a narrow set of drivers, which matters for investors who assume “owning the market” automatically means broad participation. Strategies built around dividends or quality attempt to address that by reweighting toward companies with stronger cash generation, profitability, and shareholder payouts, while reducing exposure to names that are expensive, fragile, or reliant on momentum alone.

The key issue is methodology. A dividend screen can improve cash-flow discipline, but it can also tilt toward mature sectors and away from faster-growing areas. That is useful when markets are under pressure, yet it means the fund is making an active factor bet rather than replicating the cap-weighted index. Quality screens add another layer by filtering for balance-sheet strength and earnings consistency, and a momentum or risk filter can help reduce “value trap” exposure. Investors should understand that these rules may also raise turnover, which can affect tracking difference and trading costs even when fees are low.

For long-term portfolio planning, the more important question is role, not label. These ETFs may be best used as a core equity sleeve with a defensive tilt, or as a way to rebalance away from stretched parts of the market without leaving equities entirely. Their diversification benefit comes from factor exposure, not from eliminating drawdown risk. That makes them most useful when paired with a clear allocation discipline and realistic expectations about cyclical underperformance.


Key Takeaways

  • The S&P 500’s gains mask uneven performance, with 31% of its companies down year to date as of October 30, 2026.
  • High-dividend and quality strategies offer approaches to maintaining equity exposure while emphasizing income and profitability.
  • WisdomTree’s Composite Risk Score screens out companies with low quality and price momentum to help avoid value traps.

The year 2026 is one for the books: record-breaking IPOs, markets pushing toward all-time highs despite ongoing geopolitical tensions all around the world and firms beating estimates against the backdrop of a race toward AI supremacy.

Things are starting to unfold, though, and the story may be more complex if one looks more closely at the composition of the benchmark indices. Take the S&P 500, for example. Year to date, it has returned 11.75%.1 More than half of that return is attributable to the top-10 companies within that index.

Figure 1: Which Stocks Drove the Rebound? Top 10 Contributors to the S&P 500’s Total Return from the March 30, 2026, Low to October 30, 2026

Table showing the top 10 contributors to the S&P 500’s rebound from March 30 to October 30, 2026, accounting for 55.04% of the index’s return.

Source: Bloomberg, data from March 30, 2026, to October 30, 2026 (latest available data).

The story for the other 490 companies is different: 31%1 of the 500 companies are down this year, and roughly 74% are down more than 10% from their all-time highs.

Figure 2: How Broad Is the S&P 500’s Performance?

Table showing S&P 500 constituents’ declines from all-time highs and median year-to-date performance, highlighting uneven participation in market gains. Data as of 30/10/2026.

Source: Bloomberg, data as of October 30, 2026 (latest available data).

Table showing S&P 500 constituents’ declines from all-time highs and median year-to-date performance, highlighting uneven participation in market gains. Data as of 30/10/2026.

Earnings have kept on growing for the past four years and are starting to appear more and more saturated. For example, Google has recently reported sales and income per share below what analysts estimated, wiping out 13% of its stock price in a single day (October 28, 2026); Amazon fell more than 7% after reporting operating income below estimates; and Intel fell nearly 30% after missing revenue targets.

Overall S&P earnings growth seems to have reached saturation, with earnings growth expected to slow to half of current levels (see Figure 3).

Figure 3: S&P 500 Year-over-Year Growth of Quarterly Consensus EPS

Bar chart showing S&P 500 year-over-year earnings-per-share growth from the first quarter of 2023 through estimates for 2027, with dotted outlines marking estimates and growth projected to slow in 2027. Data as-of date not supplied.

Source: Bloomberg, quarterly year-over-year earnings growth—estimates for the fourth quarter of 2026 and calendar year 2027. Estimates in dotted outline.

On the other hand, bond markets are giving investors the opportunity to lock in the highest yields seen in the past few years, which raises the question: is there a way for investors to navigate rough market conditions while still being exposed to equities?

We argue that defensive equities, in the form of quality and high-dividend stocks, provide one solution to the question raised.

Two Approaches to Defensive Equities

WisdomTree U.S. High Dividend Fund (DHS)

Dividend-paying stocks have a built-in buffer that could help companies withstand choppy markets better than non-dividend-paying stocks. Historically, dividends have provided a safety buffer when the broader market was down, helping hedge negative returns to some extent.

High-dividend indices have consistently outperformed the broader market in calendar years when it was down, like 2008 or 2022. In the most recent example, U.S. high-dividend-paying companies outperformed the market by nearly 14 percentage points when the S&P 500 was down 18%.

Figure 4: MSCI USA High Dividend Yield Index Outperformance vs. the Broad Index in Years the S&P 500 Fell

Bar chart showing the MSCI USA High Dividend Yield Index outperforming the S&P 500 in 2001, 2002, 2008, 2018 and 2022, with the largest margin in 2022. Data through 31/10/2026.

Source: Bloomberg, data from December 31, 1999, to October 31, 2026 (latest available data).

The reason for this is twofold:

  1. Dividends form part of the total return even when the markets go down (see Figure 5).
  2. Companies that can maintain a higher dividend, especially in times of market stress, will be companies with more robust balance sheets.

Figure 5: Cash Dividends Received Each Year on $100 Invested at End-2011 for the WisdomTree U.S. High Dividend Index

Bar chart showing annual cash dividends from $100 invested in the WisdomTree U.S. High Dividend Index at the end of 2011, with payments generally increasing through 2026. Data through 31/10/2026.

Source: Bloomberg, data from December 31, 2011, to October 31, 2026 (past 15 years).

Assuming $100 as the base value, the dividend received each year would have increased from roughly $3.4 in 2013 to nearly $8 in 2026.

Despite market drawdowns that impacted the price of the underlying stocks, the dividend payments have been resilient and have risen steadily over time.

The WisdomTree U.S. High Dividend Index offers a way to be exposed to liquid and high-dividend-paying companies by selecting the top 30% of stocks that pay the highest dividends.

The index excludes companies with a low quality and momentum score using a proprietary Composite Risk Score (CRS) mechanism. The rationale behind it is simple: strategies targeted toward value and dividend stocks could select ones where the trend and fundamentals might not be supported. WisdomTree strategies aim to avoid value traps by adding a risk management layer in the form of CRS.

The companies are weighted by the actual cash dividend paid, which provides an innovative and robust way of being exposed to such stocks.

WisdomTree U.S. Quality Dividend Growth Fund (DGRW)

When the market takes a turn for the worse, certain factors tend to underperform. Growth, value, size or momentum tend to be hit harder than other factors. Others, like the high-dividend factor covered in the last section, or quality, tend to be more resilient in such market conditions. Quality along with dividend provides investors an additional layer of protection in the form of profitability.

The WisdomTree U.S. Quality Dividend Growth Index provides exposure to profitable dividend-paying companies, targeting ones that can grow their dividends over time. As can be seen in Figure 6 below, in years when the market fell, the WisdomTree U.S. Quality Dividend Growth Index provided resilient and consistent outperformance.

Figure 6: Factor Return Relative to the Market in the Years the S&P 500 Total Return Fell

Grouped bar chart comparing returns relative to the S&P 500 across the WisdomTree U.S. Quality Dividend Growth Index and six equity factors in five down-market years, with average relative returns also shown. Quality dividend growth, quality and high dividend strategies outperformed in each year shown; data through 31/10/2026.

Source: Bloomberg, data from December 31, 2000, to October 31, 2026 (latest available data). “Factors” correspond to MSCI USA indices.

Stocks are also excluded on the basis of their CRS, described in the previous section. The remaining stocks are selected using three metrics:

  • Estimated earnings growth, trailing five-year earnings growth and sales growth (50%)
  • Return on equity (25%)
  • Return on assets (35%)

This methodology allows investors to gain exposure to high-quality companies, and the weighting methodology allows investors to be more exposed to companies that will pay a higher dividend.

Conclusion

With geopolitical tensions and AI trades unfolding all around the globe, investors may find in defensive equities a convenient way of being exposed to more resilient companies while still maintaining exposure to the equity market.

Investors have several choices for gaining exposure to such stocks. High-dividend-paying companies or high-quality companies can help in navigating rough market conditions by providing investors with an extra layer of security when markets tumble. Avoiding value traps is a crucial aspect of building such strategies—WisdomTree uses a proprietary Composite Risk Score (CRS) to avoid low-quality and low-price-momentum companies.

  Original Post

Enjoyed this article? Sign up for our newsletter to receive regular insights and stay connected.

Leave a Reply